Old Poetry Poetry Poets Essays Forums

Silica

My other items

1 - 3 of 23   Show all

Guest Book

Subject:

Comments

1 - 4 of 65533   Show all
  • on After Prayers, Lie Cold by C S Lewis, on October 13, 2005
    A.A. Ah¿?

    This poem reminds me of my old friend, mentor and colleague, Watt The Farouk. As in the tantric mantra - “Oh my beloved leader Watt The Farouk are you on about¿?”

    I get hints of some kind of exploration of the link between spiritual and corporeal – at least assuming he is in fact speaking internally… which I did; but not sure what is meant…

    The enjambment lines 1-2 strikes me as a little hokey but it is very difficult to judge how it was then – after all a cliché wasn’t clichéd when it was coined… in fact it is simply a victim of its own success!

    If it was on AP general list I would have probably questioned the use of whipt = whipped… but since C. S. was a lecturer in medieval and renaissance English - if he liked it – it suits me fine¡!

    I was a bit disappointed – not a false-backed wardrobe in sight – but since he hung out with J. R. R. Tolkien (among others) I guess he had to get real sometimes…

    I shall be very interested to see what the right answer is though¡!



    Edited on Oct 15, 3:28 because ''.

  • I agree with Nam – perhaps also this is not a great translation but as it stands I would throw this tiddler back in the ocean of words…

  • on Juliet by Hilaire Belloc, on March 17, 2005
    I love Belloc's poetry but have never discovered who 'Juliet' in these and several other verses actually was!
    Is this known? I suspect she was a married woman - see 'Towards the closing of her splendid day...'

  • I promoted it thinking I was getting a few to read it – clearly simply reading is not enough… just like you I think the whole thrust and particularly the last stanza is as near as we are going to get to perfection!